Market research has a reputation for being expensive, slow and academic. None of that is true for a small business. This eBook gives you a working method you can run in a week, with nothing more than a browser, a notebook and a willingness to read carefully and ask a few good questions.
Members ebook·7 chapters· 35 minute read
Chapter 3
Reading Competitor Signals
How to learn what's working in your market by carefully reading the businesses already in it.
Competitors are the most generous source of free market research a small business has. They've already tested offers, written copy, tried prices and learned what their customers respond to. All of that is sitting on their websites, social profiles and review pages, waiting for anyone willing to read it carefully.
Most owners either avoid looking at competitors at all or look at them in the wrong way. The avoiders feel uncomfortable seeing other people doing well in the same space. The wrong-way lookers obsess over every change a competitor makes and start copying. Neither approach helps. The useful posture sits between the two: read carefully, learn from the patterns and use what you find to sharpen your own thinking.
This chapter gives you a method. By the end you'll know how to pick the right five competitors to study, what to look for on each one and how to write up the findings in a way that informs decisions instead of triggering envy or panic.
The full chapter walks through the five-competitor method, the audit grid you fill in for each one and the patterns to watch for across the set.
Pick five competitors, not twenty
Five is the right number. Fewer than that and you miss the patterns. More than that and you stop reading carefully and start skimming. The five should be the businesses your target customer would seriously consider as alternatives to you.
Three of them should be direct competitors - same kind of business, same kind of customer, similar location or distribution. Two should be adjacent - businesses solving the same problem with a different approach. For a local plumbing firm, the three direct ones are other local plumbing firms. The two adjacent ones might be a regional emergency call-out service and a property maintenance company that includes plumbing. Adjacent competitors often reveal the most interesting moves.
What to look at on each one
Open a spreadsheet with one row per competitor and one column for each of the following. Homepage promise. Target customer (who their copy seems to speak to). Main offer or service. Pricing if it's public. Channel mix (which platforms they're active on). Review count and average rating. Tone of voice. One thing they do unusually well. One visible weakness.
An hour per competitor is plenty. You're not trying to write a strategic analysis. You're trying to fill in nine columns honestly.
What to actually open and read
Their homepage and one services or product page.
Their About page (it usually reveals the target customer more clearly than the homepage).
Their Google Business Profile or equivalent local listing.
Their last fifteen reviews on Google or Trustpilot.
Their last ten social posts on whichever platform they post most often on.
If they have a newsletter signup, sign up. Read whatever lands in your inbox over the next two weeks.
Reading the patterns
After all five rows are filled in, step back and look across the table. The interesting findings are almost always in the patterns, not the individual cells. Three questions to ask.
First: what does everyone in this market promise? If all five competitors lead with the same promise, that promise has stopped being a differentiator. It's table stakes. You need to deliver it but not lead with it.
Second: what do most of them ignore? If four out of five never mention price publicly, the fifth one that does is making a deliberate choice. If none of them have a clear About page, a strong founder story would stand out. Gaps are as informative as patterns.
Third: where does the language disagree? If two competitors describe the same service in completely different words, the customer is hearing inconsistent messaging across the market. That's an opportunity for you to use the clearest version of the language and be remembered for it.
Spotting the weak spots
Competitor reviews are the fastest path to weak spots. Read the three- and four-star reviews more carefully than the one-star or five-star ones. Five-star reviews tell you everyone is happy. One-star reviews tell you about a small group of unhappy edge cases. Three- and four-stars are where customers describe what they wished had been better. That's where your opportunity sits.
Common patterns: slow responses, confusing pricing, no follow-up, hard-to-find phone numbers, jargon-heavy websites, inconsistent service across team members. Each one is a chance to be visibly better without being more expensive.
What to do with the audit
Pick one differentiator. Pick one promise you'll lead with that the others don't. Pick one weakness you'll deliberately avoid. Three choices, written on one page, kept somewhere visible. Anything more elaborate stops being useful.
What to do this week
Open a spreadsheet. List the five competitors. Spend an hour on each over the next five days. On the sixth day, sit down and write the three choices: the lead promise, the differentiator, the weakness to avoid. Stick the page on your wall. The earlier book 'Positioning Your Business' uses these three choices as raw material.
Make the offer clear. Most of what looks like a competitor advantage is just clearer language about the same thing. The next chapter goes to the place where customer language lives unfiltered: reviews and forums.
The rest of this chapter walks through the practical steps, the templates and the checklists you need to put it into action. It includes worked examples, copy frameworks and the small decisions that make the difference between a plan that sits in a drive and one that gets used.
Inside you'll find a step-by-step playbook, a downloadable template, a checklist you can run this week and a short list of common mistakes to avoid before you start.
The full action plan, broken into weekly steps.
Ready-to-use scripts, templates and checklists.
Worked examples for different sized businesses.
Common mistakes and how to avoid them.
Members-only chapter
Become a member to read the full chapter
Members get the complete chapter, the step-by-step plan, the templates and the checklists. Cancel anytime.
