Most owners-to-be don't have an ideas problem. They have a choosing problem. This eBook gives you a five-filter test, a one-week sizing method and a way to pick between two ideas you both like, so you stop polishing a list and start building a business.
Members ebook·7 chapters· 45 minute read
Chapter 4
Reading the Competition Without Copying It
How to look at the businesses already serving your customer, learn what works and find the gap they're leaving.
Once you've found demand, the next question is whether anyone is already serving it well. The honest answer is usually "sort of." Few markets are completely empty and few are completely full. Most have three to ten existing options, two of which are dominant, two of which are quietly excellent and small, and the rest of which are mediocre and could be replaced. Your job in this chapter is to read that landscape clearly enough to know where you fit.
The trap most owners-to-be fall into is one of two extremes. The first is to look at the dominant competitor and conclude the market is full. The second is to ignore competition entirely and assume "my version will be different." Both are wrong. The honest middle ground is that competition tells you the market is real, the existing options tell you what "good" looks like and the gaps tell you where to start.
By the end of this chapter you'll have a one-page competitor map for your idea, a clear picture of what the market currently does well, what it does badly and where the gap is large enough to fit a new business.
The full chapter walks through the five-competitor scan, the four things to note about each competitor, the patterns that tell you a market is too crowded vs ripe and what to do when you can't find any competitors.
The five-competitor scan
Pick the five businesses your target customer would also consider when looking for what you're proposing to sell. Not the ten biggest in the country - the five your specific customer would realistically be choosing between. For a local plumber, that's the five plumbers within a thirty-minute drive who advertise online. For a national online stationer, that's the five Etsy and Shopify shops that come up in the top search results for "bespoke wedding invitations."
Spend ninety minutes on each. Read the home page, the about page, the services or product pages, the prices, the reviews and the social feed. Take notes in the same template for each, so you can compare them on a single page at the end.
What to note about each competitor
Customer: who they're explicitly written for. Not who they hope reads the site - who the headline names.
Offer: what they actually sell, in their own words. The packages, the prices, the obvious bundles.
Promise: what they explicitly or implicitly promise the customer will get. Speed, quality, price, expertise, niche understanding.
Weakness: what's missing, vague or off-putting. Slow loading site, no prices, generic photos, no reviews recent in the last twelve months, awkward booking process.
Reading the pattern
Once you have five competitor profiles, lay them side by side. The patterns will jump out. The five plumbers might all be vague about price, all use stock photos, all promise "reliable, friendly service" and none of them mention specific kinds of job. That tells you several things at once: the market is competing on trust signals (or not competing at all), price transparency is a viable differentiator, and a plumber who specialises clearly in one type of work (boilers, bathrooms, emergency leaks) would stand out immediately.
The five wedding stationers might all sit at the same price point, all show similar styles and all have a six-month lead time. That tells you the market is crowded at a particular price and style, but might be open to a faster turnaround at a higher price (urgent reorders, last-minute orders) or a much cheaper basic option for budget-conscious couples.
The four kinds of gap
Gaps in a market come in four shapes. Customer gaps: a kind of customer no existing competitor speaks to clearly (the bookkeeper for solo dentists in a market full of generalist firms). Offer gaps: a shape of offer nobody is currently selling (a one-off setup service in a market full of monthly retainers). Promise gaps: a quality of service nobody is explicitly promising (a forty-eight hour turnaround in a market where everybody quietly takes two weeks). Channel gaps: a way of being found that nobody is using well (the local plumber with no Google Business Profile, the wedding stationer with no Instagram presence).
Most strong new businesses occupy two or three of these gaps at once. "The bookkeeper specifically for solo dental practices, with same-day enquiry response, found through dental supplier partnerships" hits a customer gap, a promise gap and a channel gap. That's not crowded territory - that's three differentiators stacked on top of each other, each on its own often enough to win.
When the market looks crowded
If your initial five competitors all look strong, look harder at sub-segments. A market that's crowded at the top is often empty in the middle or at the edges. The town with three excellent estate agents at the high end might have nobody serving the lower price band. The country with twenty established marketing agencies for SaaS startups might have nobody for non-tech small businesses. Crowding at one level rarely means crowding at every level.
If even the sub-segments are full, accept it. A market with no obvious gap is a market that's working as it should. Pursuing it anyway means competing on quality and reputation against people with a ten-year head start. That's a long, slow road. There's usually a better idea among the rest of your candidate list.
When you can't find any competitors
An empty market is more often a sign of no demand than a sign of a hidden opportunity. Before you congratulate yourself on a virgin field, go back to the demand chapter and check carefully whether anyone actually wants what you're proposing. If they do and there are genuinely no competitors, ask why. Sometimes there's a regulation that closes the market, or a margin structure that makes it unviable for anyone except a giant. The absence of competition is a question, not an answer.
The genuinely good version of "no competitors" is when you've defined your customer narrowly enough that no existing business specifically serves them, but the customer clearly buys this kind of service from generalist providers. That's a niche opportunity - the market exists, it's currently served broadly, and you're proposing to serve a slice of it specifically.
What to do this week
Build your five-competitor map for your top candidate idea. Spend ninety minutes per competitor. Lay them side by side. Note the patterns and the gaps. Write a single paragraph at the end naming where you'd fit and why. If you can't write that paragraph honestly, the idea isn't ready to move on - either go back to demand sizing with a different angle or take your second-highest candidate through the same exercise.
Make the offer clear. The principle that runs through this chapter and the next. The next chapter, on the smallest testable version, takes the gap you've found and shows you how to test demand for it cheaply, before you commit. The companion eBook 'Designing Your First Offer' goes deeper into the offer shape once you've chosen which gap to target.
The rest of this chapter walks through the practical steps, the templates and the checklists you need to put it into action. It includes worked examples, copy frameworks and the small decisions that make the difference between a plan that sits in a drive and one that gets used.
Inside you'll find a step-by-step playbook, a downloadable template, a checklist you can run this week and a short list of common mistakes to avoid before you start.
The full action plan, broken into weekly steps.
Ready-to-use scripts, templates and checklists.
Worked examples for different sized businesses.
Common mistakes and how to avoid them.
Members-only chapter
Become a member to read the full chapter
Members get the complete chapter, the step-by-step plan, the templates and the checklists. Cancel anytime.
