The fourth eBook in the Retention category. It picks up where the upsells eBook left off and asks what happens when the customer relationship deepens beyond money. Loyalty schemes, member tiers, events, online communities and local relationships, all sized for a small business that can't afford a community manager.
Members ebook·7 chapters· 45 minute read
Chapter 5
Online Communities and When Not to Start One
Why most small business online communities fail, the small number that work and the honest test for whether yours should exist.
There's a temptation, after reading a chapter on events, to immediately start a Facebook group or a WhatsApp community for your customers. Resist it for a moment. Most small business online communities fail quietly. They get launched in a burst of energy, populate with twenty enthusiasts and the owner, then go silent within three months. The owner ends up either talking to themselves or quietly closing the group at year-end with a polite message about 'taking the conversation back to email'.
This chapter is about how to tell whether yours is one of the few that should exist, and if so, how to run it so it doesn't follow that path. It also looks at the lighter alternatives - a small WhatsApp list, an email-only forum, a private newsletter - that often do more loyalty work than a full group ever could.
By the end of the chapter you'll know whether to start an online community at all and, if you do, what shape will fit your business and your time.
The full chapter covers the three honest tests for an online community, the lighter alternatives, the rules of engagement and how to wind one down gracefully if it isn't working.
Why most small business online communities fail
Three reasons, most of them avoidable. The first is that the customers don't actually want to talk to each other. They're happy to talk to you, but they have no shared interest deep enough to sustain conversation between themselves. A community without peer-to-peer conversation is just a one-way newsletter wearing the wrong clothes.
The second is that the owner doesn't have the time to host the group properly. Running an active online community is a real time commitment - half an hour a day at minimum, often more in the early months. Owners who underestimate this end up with a half-tended group that goes stale.
The third is that the platform mismatches the audience. A Facebook group for a B2B accountancy firm. A LinkedIn community for a yoga studio. A Discord for a bakery. The audience never quite shows up because the meeting place feels wrong.
The three honest tests before you start
Before launching anything, run three tests. First: are your customers already trying to talk to each other through you? Are they emailing each other through your inbox, asking who else uses you, swapping recommendations between themselves at events? If yes, the appetite is real. If no, you'd be inventing it.
Second: do you have at least an hour a day, every day, for the first three months to host the group actively? Posting questions, replying to members, welcoming new joiners, gently moderating. If not, don't start. A neglected group does more reputational damage than no group at all.
Third: do you know which platform your customers actually use comfortably? If they're already in WhatsApp groups for the school, the sports club and the book group, a WhatsApp community will land. If they barely use social media, a Facebook group will sit empty regardless of how well you promote it.
Three honest tests before starting an online community
Customers are already trying to talk to each other through you
You can give the group an hour a day for the first three months
You know which platform your customers already use comfortably
Lighter alternatives that often do more
If any of those tests fails, you're better off with one of the lighter alternatives, all of which produce real loyalty without the maintenance burden of a full group.
The first alternative is a small WhatsApp list. Not a group, a broadcast list. You send a short message every couple of weeks to a list of 20 to 60 customers who opted in. They reply privately if they want to. There's no group dynamic to maintain. Loyalty effect: surprisingly large.
The second alternative is a private newsletter. A simple email list, members-only, with content that doesn't appear publicly anywhere. The bookshop's monthly recommendation list. The studio's wellbeing notes. The accountancy firm's small-business briefing. Members appreciate the privacy of the channel as much as the content.
The third alternative is a single annual gathering. One event a year that customers anticipate. The summer party. The Christmas evening. The autumn breakfast. Loyalty work via memory rather than via daily contact. Often more sustainable for businesses with one to ten people.
If you do start an online community
If all three tests pass and you decide to start a community, three rules of engagement that travel well.
Rule one: post first, every time, for the first three months. Don't wait for members to start conversations. Seed three or four threads a week yourself - questions, observations, useful links, customer stories. Members will start posting once they see what good looks like. If you stop seeding, the group goes quiet within weeks.
Rule two: reply to every post in the first six months, even if just with a thank-you. Members need to feel heard. Once the community is established, replies can become more selective.
Rule three: keep the rules short, simple and visibly enforced. Two or three sentences in the group description. No spam, no selling between members without permission, treat each other well. Quietly remove anyone who breaks them. A well-moderated small group is far more valuable than a free-for-all big one.
Worked example: a small online community that works
An independent yarn shop runs a private members-only Facebook group of about 200 customers. The owner posts three times a week - a new arrival, a project of the week, a finished-piece show-and-tell. Members post their work, ask for help with patterns and recommend each other for commissions. The shop's repeat purchase rate among group members is roughly twice that of customers not in the group. Time investment from the owner: about 45 minutes a day.
Worked example: a community that should never have existed
A small accountancy firm started a private LinkedIn group for clients in 2022. They imagined clients would discuss tax changes and exchange business referrals. Clients did neither. The group sat empty except for the partners' occasional posts, which got little engagement. After 18 months the firm wound it down quietly with a thank-you message and moved the same content into a private monthly newsletter, which clients actually read.
Winding down gracefully
If your community isn't working, close it cleanly. Send a personal message to members thanking them, explaining briefly that the format isn't fitting and offering to keep them in touch via a lighter channel - a private newsletter, a WhatsApp list, the existing email list. Don't apologise excessively. Don't drag it out. Members appreciate the honesty and most will accept the new format.
What to do this week
Run the three honest tests for your business. Write down the answers. If any test fails, choose one of the three lighter alternatives and start it next week. If all three pass, decide which platform fits, sketch the first month of seed posts and pick a launch date about three weeks away. Either way, the decision should take an hour. Most businesses end up choosing one of the lighter alternatives, and they're right to.
The recurring principle here is the same as the rest of the eBook: keep existing customers close. The earlier eBook to revisit is Email Marketing for Small Businesses, which covers the practical skills behind the lighter alternatives in this chapter. The next chapter, Local Relationships and Partnerships, looks outwards from your customer base into the wider network of small businesses around you.
The rest of this chapter walks through the practical steps, the templates and the checklists you need to put it into action. It includes worked examples, copy frameworks and the small decisions that make the difference between a plan that sits in a drive and one that gets used.
Inside you'll find a step-by-step playbook, a downloadable template, a checklist you can run this week and a short list of common mistakes to avoid before you start.
The full action plan, broken into weekly steps.
Ready-to-use scripts, templates and checklists.
Worked examples for different sized businesses.
Common mistakes and how to avoid them.
Members-only chapter
Become a member to read the full chapter
Members get the complete chapter, the step-by-step plan, the templates and the checklists. Cancel anytime.
